Instead, I’m going to tell you how I ended up falling for a gay guy who I’ve secretly been in love with for over a year. Sorry to disappoint but that’s not what this story is about. You probably think I’m about to share some hot erotic story with you based on the title of this page. But I ended up falling in love with a guy from my gym and I’m starting to question my sexual orientation. I’ve been attracted to women my entire life and have had zero physical attraction to dudes.